Some Problems with STV in Malta


Problems Encountered or Perceived:


Disproportionality in Maltese Elections


"Wasted" Votes and "Excess" Votes on the Last Count 

Minority governments and minimal voter "mandates" 

 Some items on the under-representation of women 

 "Who Needs Transfer Votes?"

 Disproportionality in District Sizes 

Tactical Termination of Candidacies 


Reform Proposals and Discussions

The 1990 Government White Paper
The text of a document which proposed wide-ranging changes in the electoral system.

 The 1994 Gonzi Commission Report

Discussion and proposals for electoral reform.

 The 1994 Buhagiar report 

A sweeping proposal for change, in a report solicited by the Gonzi Commission.

"The Priority Queue"  

A paper by Anton Buhagiar on the equitable distribution of each party's share of parliamentary seats.

 Electoral Reform Debate, 1995 - 1996 

Press accounts of the failed attempt to promote proportionality in the electoral system.


Return to Main Index Page